David Greenfield
    Framing the Research Problem    Force Field Analysis    Ubiquitous Technology: The Cell Phone  
    Literature Review    Cycle One Report    Elevator Pitch    Cycle Two Report: Data Analysis  
   Final Report    Blogs    Related Work    About David Greenfield    Contact  •  Home    
 

Ubiquitous Technology
Our friend, The Cell Phone

Introduction

The cell phone is probably the most ubiquitous technologies currently available. This is because of two primary reasons: 1) The technology successfully addresses one of the most primal needs of humanity- to communicate with other humans and 2) The communications companies have invested large sums of money for development and marketing of cell phones to insure that it has the highest penetration rate of just about any technology into just about every society on the world.  

Doing initial stages of research, I heard many anecdotal stories about people using cell phone to receive information (messages to aid in guided tours of parks and museums, text message announcements about classes or content). But as a learner whose preferred method of learning is by doing and not just reading, my challenge was to discover how to use a phone in a learning environment as a production tool and not just as a receiver of data. I was suffering from thinkers block until I attended a session at NACOL (North American Council for Online Learning) and heard and saw Hall Davidson of the Discovery Network demonstrate real time pod casting with a cell phone and the web site Gcast. One call to a general phone number with a discreet access PIN gives the user the ability to create real time audio files as both RealPlayer and MP3 formats. I suddenly was faced with endless possibilities of how to incorporate the cell phone into any and every subject

I have a long time interest in developing projects that use technology for story telling and community building, so my initial thoughts related to how this could be done. One easy solution is to send a group of learners on an adventure/learning experience/field trip where part of the assignment would be to use a cell phone to capture images and audio reflections that would be immediately published to a web site that could then be accessed by their complete learning community to both read and make comments.

The technology portion of this idea seemed accessible and easy to use, but another problem arose. I currently work as an independent consultant and designer so I have no immediate access to groups of students, with the exception for my own children’s classes. I also am aware of the general wariness of many educators to both technology and for parent’s ideas for enhancing their children’s education.


Processes of Using a Cell Phone for Media Production


I. Create accounts
    Choose online tool-
        •  Suggested for audio- Gcast (http://www.gcast.com/) or Gabcast (http://www.gabcast.com/)
        •  Suggested for image- flickr (www.flickr.com/) or del.icio.us (http://del.icio.us/)
        •  Suggested for multi-media- clicky (http://www.clicky.com/) or picotation (http://www.picostation.com/)

II. Creating Audio Pod Casts
    1) Call number provided by service
    2) Enter PIN
    3) Speak
    4) Close call
    5) Visit URL to listen

III. Adding Images and Video
    1) Take photograph
    2) Send access number
    3) Organize images on web site
    4) Distribute URL

VI. Tools Used
Motorola Razr V3 cell phone, Belkin stereo recorder, Apple GarageBand

My Research Adventure
I first met with the director of my daughter’s school. She said “no”. She liked the general idea but said that she had no time to discuss anything pertaining to technology. I then spoke with my daughter’s teacher who said a resounding “yes”, but not until Spring (because their curriculum is completely tied up to then).

I presented my idea to a friend of mine who is a teacher at a downtown L.A. school. He was not convinced, but agreed to take a letter to the principal for me. My email was returned to me by my friend with the comment that it did not address the school’s, city’s or state’s educational goals and questioned why it was different from MySpace. I replied that first, thus is a graduate research project, so that it does not have to exactly fit the school’s educational mandate (he agreed) and that it is very unlike MySpace in that the content is completely generated by the cell phone and only viewed on a computer. Also, it is not structured on an individual’s interests, but rather is structured on the shared experience of a group of learners about a specific topic or experience with the spirit of a building a collaborative presence, similar to the collaborative cognition used in creating space. This contact too seemed to be at a wall.

My next visit was to the director of my son’s school. He was excited about the idea and also had a specific project in mind. Their school is partnered with school in Tel Aviv Israel. The students write to each other 8th graders of both schools do two-week visits to the partner’s school. The students of the Magen School in Tel Aviv were scheduled to be in LA two weeks after our meeting. The director suggested that he would speak to the director of the program and that I should send a note.

During this time I noticed that there was a tendency among some of the educators that I spoke with to be unable to focus on the relative simplicity of this project, since all that is really required is a cell phone, with or without a camera. A picture (or in this case an example) being worth a   thousand words, I decided to do a demo of the concept. I decided to attend the annual dia de los muertos celebration at the Hollywood Forever cemetery with only my cell phone to record the event (for the record, I also brought along my ipod and a microphone just in case). It was a great event and offered plenty of opportunities to for audio and images (I did not test the video). I took images of altars made for the occasion, and interviewed some of the artists who made them and immediately published all media: images were sent to Flickr and audio to Gcast. Later at home, I organized the audio in a Gcast browser, and the images in Flickr, adding the audio links to the image and publishing the whole site to Del.icio.us. This site can be visited here:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dagreen/281714062/in/set-72157594349031575/

The initial response was very positive so I created a new gcast account for the students. Unfortunately, the teachers seemed unable to schedule time for me to come to the school to show them what to do. Finally, on the last day of the visit I went to the school, found a couple of students (one from each school) gave them my phone and had them call the number, make a podcast and take a couple of images for the web. Here are the links that I sent to the teacher/administrators:

To View images
http://www.flickr.com/photos/49426840@N00/
Search for i.goodman, Pressman-Magen

To listen to podcast, go to:
http://www.gabcast.com/, enter 4601 in Search episodes on Gabcast

They loved it and wished that it could have happened earlier. Later I sent the URL of the pod cast to the teacher/administrators and received a reply that that this is a great idea and that we need to speak about this more (leading me to believe that they never really looked at the message). Currently, we are in dialogue about collaborative projects that we will start at the beginning of the next semester and will include the spring visit of our students to Tel Aviv.

Along with pursuing the school projects, I began to think that this type of project could provide me with the foundation for my ARP. The basis of this project is on integrating technology to foster collaborations between schools and museums that promote learning and community building. Because of the market penetration of the cell phone is much higher than the computer, I began to feel that the cell phone might be a way to successfully lower the entry point of the digital divide. I approached the director of the Zimmer Children’s Museum in Los Angeles with the idea and we have entered into a dialogue about creating a program for the museum using cell phones as a production tool. The director is especially interested because of iTeach, their museum outreach program that goes out to schools in the inner city and other low-income areas. These are schools that do not always have new or recent computers, where existing computers may be broken, the teachers lack the time or training to use technology and where students probably do not have home computers. But, there are cell phones that can be used in creative, non-threatening and lo-tech ways.

On another note, I have also begun discussions with a friend and colleague who have a software development company. One of his projects has been the development of an open source application supporting school and museum learning partnerships. He is intrigued by the simplicity and depth of the concept as well as the complexity of the technology (for the programmer, not the user). It will be interesting to see if and where this leads.  

Final Reflection
What started as a research assignment to evaluate how a ubiquitous technology can be integrated into a learning environment has become much bigger then originally thought and in some ways has gathered a life of its own. I am convinced that it is a good tool that can help bridge the digital divide by providing a more accessible entry point. This can lead a learner to larger, more complex, interesting and fun projects using computers, cameras, audio recording tools, authoring and media production tools and more. In an ideal world, these computers will be readily available to all students and learners in any district. This is not the case in the real world, so why wait when another more readily technology is available at just about everybody’s fingertips.